In the world of microphones, two names often come up when looking for an ideal option for both studio and live applications: the Audix i5 and the Shure SM57.
Widely considered workhorses in capturing guitar tones, snare drums, and a range of other instruments, both mics have earned their place in the spotlight.
But how do they fare when pitted against each other, especially in terms of frequency response and acoustics? Is one better suited for drum kits, while the other excels with Fender guitars?
From snare drum clarity to mid-range speaker quality, this article aims to dissect the nuances of these two iconic microphones, providing you with a comprehensive comparison.
Whether you’re looking to mic a conga or wondering how each performs in terms of frequency, this article has you covered.
Audix i5 vs Shure SM57: The Battle of Dynamic Instrument Microphones
When it comes to dynamic microphones that serve both studio and live needs, the Audix i5 and Shure SM57 consistently rank at the top of the list.
These two microphones have gained immense popularity for capturing a myriad of sounds, including guitars, snare drums, and other musical instruments.
So, which microphone is the better option? We’ll explore key aspects like frequency response, acoustics, and compatibility with instruments like drum kits and guitars from renowned brands like Fender.
Frequency Response and Acoustic Quality
Audix i5
The Audix i5 features a frequency response ranging from 50Hz to 16kHz, allowing it to capture a broad array of sounds.
Its tailored frequency response ensures excellent audio quality and minimizes distortion, even at high sound pressure levels (SPLs) exceeding 140dB.
When miking instruments like snare drums and guitars, it presents a natural and accurate representation of the sound source.
Shure SM57
On the other hand, the Shure SM57 boasts a contoured frequency response that delivers clean, instrumental reproduction along with rich vocal pickup.
It is especially renowned for its professional-quality reproduction for drum and instrument amplifier miking.
Both microphones employ a cardioid pickup pattern, enabling them to isolate the main sound source while reducing background noise.
Comparing Acoustic Qualities
When it comes to capturing the true essence of a drum kit or guitar, the choice of microphone can greatly affect the final output.
The Audix i5 shines in offering a natural, balanced sound profile, while the Shure SM57 provides a more contoured frequency response, giving it a unique character especially favorable for vocals.
User Experiences
Audix i5 users often praise the microphone’s excellent bass response, particularly when used with an upright bass. The Shure SM57 also receives rave reviews for its rich sound, often compared favorably to more expensive microphones like the Shure SM7B.
Our Verdict
Both microphones are exceptional in their own right. However, if you prioritize a balanced, natural sound, the Audix i5 may be your go-to. If a contoured frequency response that adds character to your recordings is your aim, then the Shure SM57 may be the better option.
Durability and Construction
Material and Design
Audix i5
The Audix i5 is built with a rugged cast zinc-alloy body, making it highly resistant to wear and tear. Its tough exterior ensures it can withstand the rigors of touring and frequent stage use.
Furthermore, the materials used in its construction are designed for optimal durability, ensuring that the microphone maintains its integrity over time.
Shure SM57
Similarly, the Shure SM57 is known for its robust design. The microphone features an enamel-coated die-cast metal construction that can endure tough conditions.
It’s no wonder this microphone has been seen in everything from studio setups to presidential podiums, underscoring its durability.
Shock-Mount Systems
Audix i5
While the Audix i5 doesn’t have a pneumatic shock-mount system like the SM57, it does offer a very low-mass diaphragm, which ensures minimal mechanical noise and provides a clean, clear signal.
This makes the Audix i5 highly reliable for capturing precise audio, even in demanding situations.
Shure SM57
The Shure SM57 comes equipped with a pneumatic shock-mount system that cuts down on handling noise.
This makes the microphone highly useful in live performances where the microphone might be passed between multiple people or moved around the stage.
Weight and Portability
Audix i5
Weighing in at 0.92 pounds, the Audix i5 offers a solid feel without being too cumbersome. This makes it a reliable option for performers who may need to move around the stage or studio, providing a good balance of durability and portability.
Shure SM57
The Shure SM57 is slightly lighter, with a weight of 0.43 kilograms. This difference in weight can be significant for certain applications.
For example, it might be easier to mount the SM57 on a boom arm for extended periods, especially for broadcasters or podcasters.
Resistance to External Factors
Audix i5
The Audix i5 can handle a sound pressure level exceeding 140 dB without distortion, making it resistant to feedback and external noise.
The microphone also performs well under different temperature and humidity conditions, providing a consistent audio output.
Shure SM57
The Shure SM57 is also known for its resistance to external factors. Its unidirectional polar pattern isolates the sound source, effectively reducing background noise.
Moreover, it can also withstand high temperatures and humid conditions, which is particularly useful for outdoor performances.
Longevity and User Satisfaction
Audix i5
Users have reported that the Audix i5 remains consistent in its performance even after years of use. The microphone is commonly praised for its long-lasting build quality and its ability to deliver reliable results in a variety of settings.
Shure SM57
Likewise, the Shure SM57 has built a reputation for longevity. Its durable construction ensures that it can provide a consistent, quality audio output for many years. Many users mention having used their SM57 for decades, highlighting its enduring quality.
In evaluating durability and construction, both the Audix i5 and Shure SM57 demonstrate excellent qualities that make them strong contenders in the microphone market. Whether you value a shock-mount system, weight and portability, or resistance to external factors, both microphones have distinct advantages to consider.
User Reviews and Experiences
Audix i5 User Experience
One user mentioned rigging the Audix i5 to an upright bass and found that it provided a fantastic bass response. The microphone has also been praised for capturing excellent banjo sound in a bluegrass gospel band setting. Even when used in church services, the Audix i5 performed remarkably well.
Shure SM57 User Experience
One reviewer found the Shure SM57 to offer a rich sound that is close to the Shure SM7B when set up correctly. Users with mid-range male voices particularly found the frequency response of the SM57 to be nearly flat, making it easy to calibrate and adjust settings.
Comparing Feedback
While the Audix i5 is often hailed for its natural representation of bass and treble frequencies, the Shure SM57 excels in delivering rich vocals, especially when fine-tuned with equalization settings.
Versatility
Both microphones are versatile, but the Audix i5 has a slight edge when it comes to instrument variety, including brass and drums. Shure’s SM57 shines in vocal applications.
Summing Up User Reviews
Both microphones have garnered positive feedback for their performance, durability, and sound quality. Your choice may ultimately depend on the specific sound qualities you are looking to capture.
Conclusion
Choosing between the Audix i5 and Shure SM57 boils down to your specific needs. Both are exceptional choices for capturing live and studio sound across a variety of instruments.
However, the Audix i5 appears to excel in delivering a balanced, natural sound across musical instruments, while the Shure SM57 shines with a contoured frequency response beneficial for vocals.
Either way, you can’t go wrong with these robust, high-quality dynamic microphones.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Audix i5 good for vocals?
The Audix i5 is primarily designed as an instrument microphone, optimized for capturing the sound of musical instruments in live settings. However, it does have a tailored frequency response and a cardioid polar pattern that allows it to handle vocals as well. The microphone can handle sound pressure levels exceeding 140 dB without distortion, making it a viable option for vocal applications where you don’t want to compromise on audio quality. That said, while the Audix i5 can be used for vocals, there are other microphones specifically designed for vocal capture that might offer better tonal qualities for that application.
What is the difference between i5 and SM57 snare?
Both the Audix i5 and Shure SM57 are commonly used for miking snare drums, but they do have distinct sonic characteristics:
- Frequency Response: The Audix i5 has a frequency response ranging from 50Hz to 16kHz. The Shure SM57 also has a contoured frequency response designed for instrumental and vocal pickup. The differences in frequency response may contribute to different tonal characteristics; the i5 might be perceived as having a more extended low-end, while the SM57 may offer a brighter top end.
- Sound Pressure Levels: The Audix i5 can handle sound pressure levels up to 140 dB without distortion, which makes it excellent for high-SPL sound sources like a snare drum. The Shure SM57 also excels in high-SPL environments, though exact specifications may vary.
- Design: The Audix i5 features a flat cap design, ideal for close-miking applications. The SM57 doesn’t have a flat cap but is still commonly used for close-miking snares.
- Shock-Mount System: The Shure SM57 comes with a pneumatic shock-mount system to minimize handling noise, while the Audix i5 relies on its very low-mass diaphragm to maintain a clean, clear signal.
Does Audix i5 need phantom power?
The Audix i5 is a dynamic microphone, which means it does not require phantom power to operate. Dynamic microphones generate their own electric charge in response to sound waves, eliminating the need for external power. Simply plug the Audix i5 into an XLR input, and it’s ready to use.
Why use SM57 on snare drum?
The Shure SM57 is a popular choice for snare drums for several reasons:
- Tonal Quality: The SM57 has a contoured frequency response that enhances the natural characteristics of a snare drum, offering a clean and rich sound.
- High SPL Handling: The microphone can handle high sound pressure levels, making it ideal for loud sound sources like snare drums.
- Durability: Known for its robust construction, the SM57 can withstand the physical abuse that often comes with live performances.
- Cardioid Polar Pattern: This helps isolate the snare drum from other instruments in the drum kit or on stage, reducing bleed and allowing for a more focused sound.
- Industry Standard: The SM57 is an industry standard for snare drum miking, which means that it’s a tried and true option that many sound engineers and musicians rely on for consistent results.
Both the Audix i5 and the Shure SM57 have their merits, particularly when it comes to miking snares. Your choice between the two will likely depend on specific tonal preferences, the nature of your application, and any additional features you may value.
